Cancer in Totnes
Because of its content, I immediately complained to Consumer Direct (the central point for Trading Standards complaints) on 2 March who passed it on to Devon Trading Standards (TS).
Unfortunately, the online form for Consumer Direct is limited to 2,500 characters, so I had to limit what I said, but I hoped this would be sufficient to get TS interested and investigating:
I am very concerned about a conference to be held in Totnes Civic Hall on 24 March 2012 – see http://www.totnescancerhealthcentre.com/an-alternative-view-cancer-conference/ (Cached at http://www.freezepage.com/1330710868PPVPSWSRQD)
The conference is open to the general public and is titled: An Alternative View | Cancer Conference.
“Dr.Tullio Simoncini – Italian Oncologist for 15 years and author of the book “Cancer is a Fungus” will speak about sodium bicarbonate as a treatment.
Dr. Robert Verkerk – From the Alliance for natural health will discuss environmental causes of disease and cancer.
Matthew Manning – Internationally renowned Psychic/spiritual Healer and Author, will speak about his vast experience as a healer and psychic.
Barbara Wren – International Author, Principle of The College of Natural Nutrition. Barbara will speak on the core principles of health cultivation.
Dr. Stephen Hopwood. 20 years experience as a Holistic Physician and Traditional Chinese Physician.
Alan Papier. 30 years experience as a Chinese herbalist, Alan will discuss cancer from the TCM viewpoint using a power-point presentation in association with Giovanni Maciocia.
John Hagger. A cancer survivor using “The Gerson Therapy” John will share his experiences and insights and lecture on the principles of Gerson therapy.
Kevin Wright founder of ’Bobby’s Health Fund’ speaks about his sons natural cure and his commitment to educate and support the public about cancer health care.
Dr Sarah Myhill will give an address to the conference on her perspective on treating cancer.
Film: “Cancer – The Forbidden Cures – 1hr 30 min documentary outlining historical cures.”
The names of the speakers are linked to pages giving more details of their talks.
I am concerned that this conference may breach the Cancer Act 1939 and could be highly dangerous and misleading to the general public.
I am also concerned that some of the speakers may not be on the GMC’s List of Registered Medical Practitioners.
I am also concerned about many other pages on this website (www.totnescancerhealthcentre.com) and request that you review all of them.
Because this conference is only 3 weeks away, please treat this complaint as a matter of urgency.
A few days later, Andy Lewis wrote an excellent blog post about it, highlighting the vulnerability of those seeking ‘miracle’ cancer cures: The Totnes Cancer Health Centre: A Quack Pascal’s Wager.
I contacted Plymouth Skeptics in the Pub (SitP) and other skeptics in the area and they started to think about what could be done to help.
It was been mentioned on Twitter by the SitP organiser and the local MP and ex-GP, Dr Sarah Wollaston expressed concern. She then also complained to Devon TS and this was discussed on BBC Radio Devon’s Good Morning Devon show this morning. The relevant segments are (click on the times to go directly to that segment of the show):
Note that the programme will only be available until 27 March.
The last segment with Hopwood went like this:
Hopwood: She [Dr Sarah Wollaston MP] didn’t do me the courtesy of actually communicating or with me or coming and having a look at what we were doing or asking about our ethos…
I think it’s a little bit impolite. I’d suggest that if she was a little bit more committed to local businesses and a little bit more in tune with the spirit of Totnes which has built its reputation on complementary medicine, then she would have had the courtesy to come in and discuss with me who’s been running the Arcturus clinic in the centre of town for the last 15 years about the principles and practices of what we do here.
Interviewer: She’s concerned about this word cure and whether the way in which you promote yourselves here at the clinic is kept within the Cancer Act 1939.
Hopwood: I’m absolutely committed to working within those legislative boundaries and if you take the time to read our disclaimer on page 23 of the brochure or if you read our important notice that appears on the bottom of every single page of our website then you will see that we’re absolutely committed to working within those guidelines.
Interviewer: Are you happy that that’s on page 23 of your brochure and at the bottom of your website as opposed to within the main body of the text?
Hopwood: Em yes. It’s clear from everything that we say, time and time again, that we don’t aim to treat cancer; that is not our endeavour that is not our intention we don’t believe that that’s what we’re doing we’re not trying to do that.
Interviewer: Are you treading a thin line?
Hopwood: Yes there is a thin line because the pharmaceutical industry is very touchy about its monopoly over the treatment of cancer…
Interviewer: But this is a law — we’re talking about the Cancer Act of 1939.
Hopwood: I’m obviously committed to staying inside the letter of the law because I continue to practise.
Interviewer: You sound quite cynical about it though.
Hopwood: I think the exponential rise in incidents of cancer in our society is a reflection of the health of our nation and the modern way in which we’re living. I think if start to get this issue, as we are, onto the public domain and start to have a public debate about what is in our best interests…
Interviewer: Is that the kind of thing you want to see your MP Dr Sarah Woollaston doing opposed to going to Devon TS and reporting you for your advertising?
Hopwood: I think to do both is fine I’m actually very happy to be in communication with the Devon trading people and I wish to have an intimate and ongoing relationship with them and I’m very happy to have them crawling all over my website and over my publicity because that’s great. They can police me as much as they like and I shall comply with everything…
Interviewer: But what about SW your MP? She’s a GP, after all.
Hopwood: She is a GP, after all, yeah…
Interviewer: So she’s not coming into it cold, is she? She has a fair amount of knowledge.
Hopwood: She has a fair amount of knowledge but she doesn’t have a great deal of knowledge about the principles and the practices of health cultivation. She has been a shop-front for the pharmaceutical industry, like most GPs, and that’s been the bread and butter of her work. And she hasn’t spent the time or put the energy into studying the details of complementary medicine so I invite her to actually come to the conference and meet the many doctors that we’re gonna have there and be in contact with the many doctors around the country and around the world that are now saying — as Prince Charles is — that holistic integrative complementary medicine needs to be integrated with our national health.
I’ll leave you to judge Hopwood’s performance in this.
Hopwood mentions the disclaimer on his website, but it’s interesting to note that it only appeared a week ago. I had Change Detection set up to monitor changes to the conference page:
Click to embiggen.
I wonder if that was the day Devon Trading Standards contacted them?
This afternoon, the story escalated and appeared on the BBC News website: Totnes cancer conference investigated by Trading Standards.
But the big news is that Totnes Radio station website has just announced: Totnes Council shuts Hopwood’s cancer conference down.
THE TOTNES cancer conference, which would have heard from a disqualified Italian doctor who believes baking powder can cure cancer, has been shut down by Trading Standards and Totnes Town Council as it contravenes strict laws against advertising cures for the disease.
The dramatic move, which was agreed by the Town Council this evening, follows a complaint about the Totnes Cancer Health Care Conference from Dr Sarah Wollaston, the MP for Totnes.
I know of several others who complained after I complained to TS, but an MP’s voice is much louder than that of a few residents or someone from the other side of the country — I am just pleased that TS have done the right thing.
Dr Wollaston said one particular issue was Dr Simoncini’s claim that cancer is a fungus that can be cured with sodium bicarbonate, otherwise known as baking soda. On his website, Dr Simoncini said he was struck-off as an oncologist, because he administrated sodium bicarbonate instead of conventional chemotherapy.
Dr Wollaston said: “If he can provide any evidence base whatsoever that sodium bicarbonate will actually alleviate symptoms, then let’s see it, but I’m afraid nobody else in the conventional cancer community would actually share his view.
“What I’m having a go at here is advertising specifically to people who are at the most vulnerable time of their lives,” she said. “There are, very rightly, safeguards in place to protect people against adverts for remedies which really have no basis in evidence.”
No doubt there will be cries about free speech, but this is not about free speech: it’s about protecting potentially vulnerable people from unproven and disproven miracle cures. As Andy concludes in his blog post:
The tragedy of alternative medicine is its total failure to find an ethical role for itself. By clinging to its delusions, it risks creating only overall harms. And, as such, it appears that legislation is the only way to protect people. If only Trading Standards were a little bit more on the ball in implementing existing laws.
It looks like Trading Standards did the right thing this time, but, unfortunately, Totnes Cancer Health Centre is by no means alone.